Hi, Chris.

I certainly agree that the letter will be helpful to us, and I am not surprised at the CYA language Ms. Froetscher included. My concern was raised by Joel's statement that "NSC shares our position on distracted driving, especially in regards to the use of amateur radio equipment". I wanted to be sure that was not an endoresment of the recomendation contained in the closing paragraphs of her letter. Dave's later reply let me know that such is not our intent.

73,

Marty N6VI

Representing car-crazy SoCal

----- Original Message -----

From: Chris Imlay

Sent: Friday, September 04, 2009 6:32 AM

Subject: Re: [arrl-odv:18077] Re:National Safety Council reply

Well, Marty, you have to focus on the operative term of the letter, which is at the end of the third paragraph:

"Until such time as compelling, peer-reviewed scientific research is presented that denotes significant risks associated with

the use of amateur radios, two-way radios, or other communications devices, the NSC does not support legislative bans

or prohibition on their use."

That is a lot further than I expected them to go. Surely you can't expect the President and CEO of the NSC to not cover herself after giving an answer like that. The suggestion that amateur mobile operation should be confined to emergency communications during

disasters is a suggestion for our own best practices document that they recommend.

I think the letter is a home run for us, frankly.

Christopher D. Imlay
Booth, Freret, Imlay & Tepper. P.C.
14356 Cape May Road
Silver Spring, Maryland 20904-6011
(301) 384-5525 telephone
(301) 384-6384 facsimile
W3KD@ARRL.ORG

Hi, Joel.

While I'm pleased to learn that NSC is not looking to promote laws prohibiting Amateur Radio mobile operation any time soon, I'm not sure that discouraging mobile operation other than in "disaster emergencies" is consistent with our - or at least my constituents' - position on the use of Amateur equipment while driving. Some people can multi-task well and others cannot. A blanket policy along the lines suggested by Ms. Froetscher is, IMHO, not a suitable substitute for the exercise of individual judgment and would be inapproriate.

73,

Marty N6VI

----- Original Message -----

From: Joel Harrison

To: arrl-odv

Sent: Thursday, September 03, 2009 6:18 PM

Subject: FW: National Safety Council reply

You will recall I recently sent a letter to the National Safety Council expressing concern that Amateur Radio operators may be impacted by the flurry of legislation aimed at distracted driving, primarily for cell phone use.

Attached is a response I received from NSC President Janet Froetscher. I appreciate her quick and factual response and I'm pleased to see NSC shares our position on distracted driving, especially in regards to the use of amateur radio equipment.

73 Joel W5ZN