Bob, I can't speak for Rev in terms of comments received from within my Division, but my understanding is that IRLP always requires a radio -- unlike Echolink, I can't talk to someone via my computer's microphone. I have to use some kind of RF link (namely a repeater) that then taps into the internet and pops back out as RF somewhere else. In that case, a license is always required, as is a radio. More experienced IRLP users are free to correct me if I'm in error. This is based on my limited use of IRLP and through referring to the IRLP website. In future replies to your members and those on the CQ Contest list, you might mention the above and recommend a visit to www.irlp.net in an effort to lay some of the preconceived notions to rest. I personally don't see a problem with ARRL specifically stating the contest's sponsorship, lack thereof, or not mentioning either. By putting it on our website we are, in essence, promoting "interest in Amateur Radio communications and experimentation," one of our reasons for being as stated on the "About the ARRL" page within our website. 73, Brian, N5ZGT ARRL Vice-Director, Rocky Mountain Division On Wed, 16 Mar 2005, R. B. Vallio wrote:
I haven' seen anyone address this on ODV, so I will bring to everyone's attention. Please take a look at:
http://www.arrl.org/news/stories/2005/03/14/3/?nc=1
before you read further.
This is an announcement of an IRLP contest, on our WebPages, with no indication of any sort that sponsorship is not by the ARRL. The CQ Contest reflector was filled with comments on March 14, the first day the announcement appeared, and although the number is down, there are still comments being made.
The thought of the ARRL sponsoring a contest where entrants need not have a radio or a license to participate, has certainly sparked some comments from Pacific Division members. I believe that there is no harm in mentioning it, but that a disclaimer of ARRL sponsorship should have been included. Have any of you folks received any mail on the subject? Thanks.
Bob -- W6RGG