Riley, Thanks for your comments. I hope we can all take them to heart in the coming year. You raise two important points. First, the importance of ham radio in ourlives, because, as you put it, “we all love the magic of radio.” We need to keep coming back to that becauseit is a shared hobby, and all of us want to see it continue, our disagreementsnotwithstanding. The second is the law of unintended consequences. You have a unique perspective on the FCC, andwe all need to listen. It would be onething if we were completely unaware of how some of the discord could affect hamradio. The consequences would still bethere. But now that we know what theycould be, it’s that much more important to listen and change. Thanks again for speaking out. Tom Delaney W8WTD On Monday, December 24, 2018, 10:16:55 PM EST, RILEY HOLLINGSWORTH <rilepatholling@comcast.net> wrote: An Open Letter to Members of the ARRL Board-- Incumbents and Newbies Today, Christmas Eve, I had the distinct pleasure of talking to Royce Goodwin, WA4AFE, and Joe Gault, W4WZ, both in the Carolinas and both in their mid 90’s. I talk to them every week, most often on CW. These guys got me in to Amateur radio as a 13-year-old, taught me the code and helped me with the theory. They are both active, in life and in radio--especially CW. When I oversaw Amateur radio enforcement at FCC, I considered myself to be working for people such as them, as well as FCC. It occurred to me that we stand on their shoulders. People like Joe and Royce gave us this wonderful avocation that joyfully occupies our lives. I cannot imagine not having radio as a major part of my life, and I suspect you feel the same-- because we all love the magic of radio. If this activity joyfully occupies our lives, why can’t we approach the duties of the ARRL Board the same way? Just because so much of society and government is dysfunctional doesn’t mean we have to be. This is our watch. We need to rid ourselves of this vitriolic attitude toward those who disagree with us. If every member of the Board always agreed on every topic, we’d only need one Director on the Board. But we can disagree without being disagreeable, and we can lose on any particular issue without seeking to burn down ARRL headquarters. None of this conflict is lost on the FCC. I still have constant contact with the FCC, and whether I go to the FCC in Washington or in Gettysburg, the first question I always get is “How is the Board getting along?” The ARRL is the ONLY voice Amateur radio has. Each month of continued infighting, back stabbing and bitterness and plotting moves us one notch closer to the outer circle on the FCC radar, i.e., towards irrelevance. We need the FCC for protection on two fronts: spectrum protection, and enforcement protection. If our biggest enemy is ourselves, and if we implode by aggravating ourselves to death, the FCC doesn’t have to give us the time of day—except in the rare legal proceeding on the scale of BPL, which costs the ARRL dearly in legal fees (but was a wonderful victory still celebrated today by some in the FCC). But those situations are extremely rare. In every other way, and on a day to day basis, we will slowly lose status and respect at the FCC and die a slow death. This is OUR watch and we owe it to the Joe Gaults and Royce Goodwins of our Amateur radio world to make sure our highest priority is not ego or revenge or getting our own way, but rather Amateur radio itself. At the end of the day, if our actions—whatever they are—have not gained one new Amateur (especially a young one) or one new League member, we are spinning our wheels. All of us are experienced enough in life by now to know that when we think we know all the answers, it’s probably because we haven’t thought of all the questions. I spent every working day and most weekends of my life for almost 10years trying to restore Amateur radio to its rightful place in the American communications infrastructure after 12 years of neglect by the FCC. That neglect was due to other priorities such as explosive growth in paging, land mobile and then cellular. Do you remember the early 90’s, when you were very afraid to demonstrate Amateur radio to anyone such as a neighbor or grandchild, for fear of what you would hear on 75 meters, or even on a repeater? We are way beyond that now and it is because the FCC respected us and appreciated our service and contributions and supported a new enforcement initiative in our service. But I implore you to realize that these vitriolic conflicts are known and watched by the FCC, which in this era has a gazillion other things to deal with besides Amateur radio; and as with every agency, it is looking for things not to have to deal with anymore. Please let’s don’t make ourselves irrelevant. I plead with you to realize that we can work together as friends and stewards of Amateur radio, paying back what we owe this joyful avocation and respectfully trying to resolve our disagreements; or we can perish together as fools. This is our time, and if there’s one thing we have learned in our time, it’s that anything can fail. _______________________________________________ arrl-odv mailing list arrl-odv@reflector.arrl.org https://reflector.arrl.org/mailman/listinfo/arrl-odv