Joel -- I got all worked up and forgot to say "good job" on the
letter. Rod
At 03:10 PM 12/18/2006, Joel Harrison wrote:
Greetings,
When all of the errors in WT Docket 04-140 became apparent with the
release of the Report & Order we all wanted a piece of Bill Cross
because of his blatant ignorance, arrogance or just plain
stupidity….whatever it was.
It was disturbing to me that he did not take a brief moment out of his
day, that I’m confident is anything but occupied with official business,
and contact Chris just to run some things by him in an attempt to prevent
the calamity of errors caused by the overexpansion of the 80 meter phone
band.
Even so, I was willing to concede what had been done had been done and
dealing with how to prevent this in the future would be a top priority
for 2007.
We filed our petition for reconsideration in good faith, attempting to
present the best possible resolution to the domino effect caused by the
expansion.
Friday morning, Chris received a phone call from Scot Stone at FCC. I
know Scot from previous meetings at FCC and quite frankly I have a lower
opinion of him than I do Cross. Under the current organizational
structure at FCC he is above Cross in the food chain. Cross was not at
work on Thursday and Friday. Stone asked Chris what he thought about FCC
moving the automatic sub-band below 3600 KHz. Chris, of course, told him
that was a horrible and idea and told him why. Stone ended the
conversation with “Well, I just wanted to let you know where we are
headed with this”. At that point, it was obvious that WTB was going to
once again make a bad situation worse.
This continued arrogance of the Wireless Bureau burned me up, so much so
that it was all I had on my mind during my trip back from D.C. Saturday
morning and through Sunday. It is one thing for the FCC to ignore us on
the BPL issue, which is a political matter. But for the WTB to ignore
ARRL on Part 97 amateur matters is just plain inexcusable!
Sunday afternoon I concluded enough was enough. It was time to let the
Commissioners know exactly how bad the WTB staff screwed up this Docket
regarding the 80 meter expansion and the incompetence that it exhibited
subsequent to the release.
One bright spot late Friday was a phone call Chris received from a
representative in Commissioner Copps office. He wanted to advise us of
the pending release of WT Docket 05-235 and what was contained in it was
not what the League had proposed and he wanted to discuss it. At that
time Chris mentioned the earlier call from Stone and expressed his
concern over the handling of our petition for reconsideration. Given the
desire of Copps office to discuss this matter I felt going to the
Commissioners with the WTB problems was the right thing to do.
It is a given fact that we will never change the Wireless Bureau by
working directly with them. They have now proven beyond a shadow of a
doubt that they will ignore the League’s expertise in amateur radio
matters. That being understood, our first course of action is to quit
beating our heads against the WTB wall and start working from the top
down.
Sunday afternoon I drafted a letter for Chairman Martin and each of the
Commissioners. I sent it to Dave and Chris for review. After some edits
we settled on a final version that has now been sent to the Chairman and
each of the Commissioners.
It is attached for your info.
While this will become a public record since it is being sent to FCC, I
do not plan any hoopla or news stories about it. This is just step one of
an objective to turn this situation around.
73 Joel W5ZN